This reappraisal is based connected a screening which took spot astatine the 2025 Fantastic Fest Film Festival. Black Phone 2 volition beryllium released theatrically successful the United States connected October 17.
In the incorrect hands, sequels tin beryllium predatory pursuits. When workplace executives ticker films similar Sinister oregon The Black Phone amass steadfast container bureau returns, the tendency to double-dip burns similar an inferno. Dollar signs (can oregon might) outweigh originative pursuits. But successful the close hands, a sequel broadens caller ideas and spawns caller potential. A sequel tin unlock storytelling you'd ne'er expect. Director Scott Derrickson and his co-writer C. Robert Cargill garbage to fto Black Phone 2 beryllium different redundant Hollywood cash-in, and by their efforts, bring america arsenic adjacent to Freddy Krueger arsenic we'll get until there's different A Nightmare connected Elm Street.
The Black Phone wasn’t intended to person a sequel, based connected a one-off Joe Hill communicative arsenic it was. Derrickson and Cargill are successful uncharted territory, which becomes their advantage. Ethan Hawke returns arsenic The Grabber, not of soma and bone; he's a boogeyman successful your nightmares, yet the symptom helium inflicts leaves existent scars. But The Grabber’s resurrection is hardly a Wes Craven knockoff. The filmmakers’ caller nightmare is an ambitious improvement of The Black Phone that proves fearfulness sequels don't person to recycle the aforesaid inexpensive thrills for different go-around. Despite borrowing Jason Voorhees' campground backdrop, this movie is not conscionable different repetitive sequel similar Friday the 13th has been known to produce.
Frankly, Black Phone 2 is simply a punk stone fearfulness sequel. Derrickson and Cargill ripen evils alternatively of playing the aged hits. The Grabber transforms from a kiddie-killing sicko to a devil's cull who took ice-skating lessons. The survivor’s guilt of the archetypal film’s Finney sees returning histrion Mason Thames playing him arsenic a haunted pot-head, portion Madeleine McGraw, besides backmost from Part 1, steps into the pb relation arsenic Finney’s sister Gwen, channeling her lucid dreams and clairvoyant abilities. Denver's quiescent suburbs are traded for blizzard conditions astatine the Alpine Lake Catholic sleepaway camp, sending wintery, frostbitten chills up our spines, brought connected by The Grabber's freezer-burned appearance. It's thing similar the original, nor does it privation to beryllium connected familiarity. The filmmakers marque the astir of their 2nd chance—this ain't a churn-and-burn continuation.
The movie is an ambitious improvement of The Black Phone that proves fearfulness sequels don't person to recycle the aforesaid inexpensive thrills for different go-around.
The murderous events of The Black Phone permission Finney and Gwen rightfully traumatized, which puts a dense accent connected quality exploration. Finney numbs the symptom with "devil's lettuce," stalked by hallucinations of The Grabber, portion Gwen answers the ringing of achromatic phones, driven by a pursuit for answers and the accidental to assistance different mislaid souls. The publication ruminates connected grief and unrest by sorting done Finney and Gwen's intelligence damage, but tin dawdle astatine times earlier The Grabber's malevolence is felt successful afloat unit erstwhile again. There's besides the summation of Demián Bichir's campy supervisor, whose biblical cognition and reliance connected religion bring holiness into a speech astir bleak-as-tar evils for added theological debates. But Black Phone 2 is ever Finney and Gwen's showcase. A brother-sister ghostbusting play that tastes awfully dour until past the halfway point, erstwhile The Grabber's clasp turns affectional hurts into gaping wounds and breathless terrors rise the ante.
That's not to accidental Black Phone 2 is lone invaluable erstwhile kiddos go cadaver popsicles. It's much the anticipation of inevitable snowscape horrors that’s nipping astatine our nose, which can't assistance but distract successful the slightest portion Finney and Gwen wrestle with lingering demons. Miguel Mora reprises his relation arsenic Ernesto Arellano, surviving connected successful his member Robin's grant arsenic Gwen's sweetheart of a emotion interest. Jeremy Davies earns redemption arsenic the present sober Terrance, the supportive and loving papa to Finney and Gwen. It's each indispensable to further specify however post-traumatic accent tin teardrop your satellite apart, paired with the hopefulness that brighter days tin prevail, but you tin consciousness the film's astir two-hour runtime. Not terribly detrimentally, yet still, there's a missing giddyup astatine times.
Past that gripe, Black Phone 2 is simply a affluent slasher enigma that transcends beingness and death. Hawke's crook arsenic a vengeful iteration of The Grabber's deceased aforesaid is occurrence and brimstone, and his flesh-rotting face, which helium exposes sans disguise to thrust location terrifying imagery, bears scorched scars from Hell. Derrickson whips retired his Super 8 camera to denote whenever Gwen has entered The Grabber's slumber realm, wherever she unsocial tin face her villain, which is simply a clever ocular interaction to differentiate betwixt world and dreamland. There's an old-school Hollyweird consciousness to these sequences, similar Gwen stars successful her ain uncanny movie, but past we're rapidly ripped backmost to (the film's) reality, wherever she's gushing humor oregon being tossed astir similar an invisible ragdoll. Derrickson ensures stakes are dreadfully existent successful either universe, unleashing unit that leaves your rima agape.
For arsenic ponderous and introspective arsenic Black Phone 2 tin be, it's inactive a caller reinvention of accepted slasher tropes. Even the stereotype astir however fearfulness sequels thin to spell bonkers is connected display, since The Grabber has an full icecapades regular connected magical frozen blades. The film's cheekiness—snowmen with The Grabber's smile, his maniacal taunts via conversation—is abundant. And yet, Black Phone 2 matters beyond dreadful realizations and hacked-in-half noggins. Derrickson and Cargill navigate the murky themes of self-imprisonment and meaningful recovery, yet conveying a wholesome message, but not earlier subjecting their characters to sedate desperation. It's a batch to digest, and sorrow weighs heavily, but astatine the extremity of it all, these filmmakers find a mode to permission america uplifted portion inactive delivering each the slashery goodness we truthful crave.
Verdict
Black Phone 2 is an effectual sequel that boils implicit with reinvigoration. Colorado's blustery wintertime conditions overgarment a pristine snowcapped backdrop for The Grabber's origins, wherever helium forces Finney and Gwen to face their demons from beyond the grave. It's much astir however survivors process trauma than it is simply a woodland sidesplitting spree, but that doesn't forestall achromatic pulverization from being splattered with humor similar a Jackson Pollock painting. Black Phone 2 mightiness instrumentality a bushed to scope apical speeds, but erstwhile everything's singing successful harmony—from The Grabber's supernatural revenge crippled to Gwen's harnessing of her medium-esque powers for good—it’s much than a worthy follow-up. The movie is simply a template for however sequels tin scope further and propulsion for standalone appeal, valuing originality implicit redundancies that reward fans alternatively of manipulating their dedication to fandoms.